False Bottom!
Oct 03, 2008 in Finance
Well… I am back from my personal hiatus.
Topic of the day is GDP, and what has changed. The last consumer led recession in the US occurred in 1978. A consumer led depression occurs when the consumer no longer has cash to spend and the economy seizes. This is different from a producer led recession where they cannot sell their product (normally overseas) and are forced to cut work at home.
Now the US on a Federal mandate, has transformed from the producer of all high-level high margin items, to the producer of virtual wealth. Instead of making cars, TVs, appliances, ships and steel… they make websites, retail everything, and “value added financial products” that are hard to value but get AAA-rated anyways.
So people used to make high margin items and now are in the service industry…who cares. Despite having a lower standard a living, and a less skilled labor force it’s not that big of a deal right? Well… 70% of the US GDP is now consumer based. A large portion of that was fueled by Home equity loans. The savings rate was negative for the last few years. People largely have negative net worth and 3.5 adjustable rate loans are going to reset this year.
Ok, so now there are more people who live paycheck to paycheck, no longer have access to credit and the economy is based on consumer spending…. does anyone else not see a problem with that? Bankruptcies are going to get worse… much worse.
Let’s just make up a simple example where you employer experiences a revenue downfall of 10%. In scenario A) you work at a factory that makes widgets and has a gross margin of 50% in B) you work for a retail store (Walmart) that makes 20% if they are lucky and they are the best. As side from the fact that you would make half or less working for Walmart, the impact to their business will be much larger, fixed costs are much higher in retail/service than they are in manufacturing.
So people lose their jobs quicker, businesses can’t get loans to help people finance things (which I think at this point is good, but not for the economy)…the economy will shrink.
This last week the media has been misreporting the Warren Buffet investment. He is not bottom feeding he is leveraging his money to make massive guaranteed gains that most people cannot do. HE IS NOT BUYING COMMON STOCK. He is also not getting normal preferred stock. If you buy into GE just because buffet did you deserve what is coming to you. The fact that GE and Goldman Sachs needed to sell to buffet at such undesirable terms speaks volumes. AIG has almost maxed their credit lines, and with Congress fumbling what used to be a $700B but is now a $1T buy-in… I don’t believe anymore in the US gov’t than I did last year.
Buffet got preffered stock which is stock that pays a dividend that is agreed upon by the issuer and the buyer. It does not appreciate like common does. It is basically a bond, with preferential tax treatment (bond income is taxed at normal income rates, dividend is capital gains). It is a perpetuity, the dividend does and can increase, and if Goldman or GE wants it back they need to pay all of his original capital plus 10% premium and Buffet keeps the dividends… which are twice what normal investors would get for preffered capital. And for his good deed of providing capital, he gets the option (warrants) to buy common stock for below market price and at no risk to ANY of his original capital.
These companies were desperate to shore up their balance sheets, and Buffet was not willing to take a risk. He basically has protected capital, guaranteed at 10% dividend and also has the chance to enjoy upside on the common stock through the warrants he received, which are already in the money…. and if you subtract their current value from his capital contribution reduce it dramatically.
Which is why they markets didn’t see it as a sign of confidence… Buyer beware. I almost bought in as the bottom yesterday. Glad I didn’t. AA, AAPL, SVC, MRVL, BRCM and RIO looking real good though…